Bourbon is one of the most tightly defined spirits in the world. Where a Scotch label can hide a great deal, a bourbon label is constrained by federal rules that dictate the grain, the barrel, the strength at several points in the process and what may be added. Learn the rules and you can predict a good deal about how the whiskey in front of you will taste.
What are the legal requirements for bourbon?
- Made in the United States. Not only Kentucky, despite the association. Bourbon is produced in Texas, New York, Colorado and elsewhere, though Kentucky remains the centre of the industry.
- At least 51 per cent corn in the mash bill, with the remainder usually rye or malted barley, and sometimes wheat.
- Distilled to no more than 80 per cent alcohol. This ceiling keeps flavour compounds in the spirit rather than stripping them out.
- Entered into the barrel at no more than 62.5 per cent.
- Aged in new charred oak containers. New is the crucial word and the single biggest difference from Scotch.
- Bottled at 40 per cent or above, with nothing added but water. No colouring, no flavouring, no sweetening.
There is no minimum ageing period for bourbon in general. Straight bourbon requires two years, and any straight bourbon under four years old must state its age.
Why does new charred oak matter so much?
A fresh barrel has its full complement of vanillin, wood sugars and tannins available, and charring caramelises the inner surface. Spirit going into it takes colour and sweetness quickly, which is why a four year old bourbon is often darker than a twelve year old Scotch.
The flavour signature is consistent: vanilla, caramel, brown sugar, baking spice and a distinct sweetness from the corn. Scotch, matured mostly in barrels that already gave much of that away to a previous filling, develops more slowly and shows more of the distillery's own character.
How does the climate change things?
Kentucky summers are hot and winters are cold. Spirit expands into the wood in warm weather and contracts out of it when temperatures drop, and the cycle repeats every year. Maturation is therefore fast and extraction is aggressive.
Scotland has neither the heat nor the swing. Maturation is slow and gentle, and a whisky can sit for two decades without becoming over-oaked. This is why age statements are not comparable between the two. A six year old bourbon and a six year old Scotch have had entirely different experiences.
Warehouse position matters in Kentucky for the same reason. Barrels near the top of a rickhouse get hotter and mature faster than those at the bottom, and blending across floors is part of the art.
What does a wheated bourbon taste like?
Where the recipe uses wheat rather than rye as the secondary grain, the result is softer and rounder, with less pepper and more bread and honey. These are described as wheated bourbons and tend to be the gentler end of the category. A high rye bourbon does the opposite, adding a dry spicy bite that carries well in an old fashioned.
What is the difference between bourbon and Tennessee whiskey?
Tennessee whiskey meets every bourbon requirement and adds one more step, the Lincoln County Process, in which new spirit is filtered through sugar maple charcoal before going into the barrel. It removes some heavier compounds and produces a slightly smoother, sootier character. Legally it could be sold as bourbon; producers choose the regional name instead.
How do the two compare in a glass?
Bourbon leads with sweetness. Expect vanilla, caramel, cinnamon and often a full oily texture. Scotch covers a far wider range, from light and floral Lowland malts to intensely smoky Islay whiskies, but even the sweetest Scotch tends to be drier than a typical bourbon.
For cocktails, bourbon's sweetness and body make it forgiving, which is why the old fashioned, the manhattan and the whiskey sour are built on American whiskey. For sipping neat, the choice is personal, though bourbon's higher average strength means water is often more useful than people expect.
Which should you buy first?
If you are new to whiskey generally, bourbon is the easier starting point because the sweetness is immediately recognisable and the price of a good bottle is lower. Start with a standard straight bourbon around 45 per cent, try it neat and then in an old fashioned, and use it as a reference point for everything else.