A cheap gin and an expensive gin can share the same base spirit from the same supplier. The gap between them comes from a handful of specific costs, and only some of those end up in the glass.
How much of the price is tax?
In the United Kingdom, most of it at the lower end. Spirits duty is charged per litre of pure alcohol, so a 70 centilitre bottle at 40 per cent attracts a fixed duty sum regardless of whether the liquid inside cost fifty pence or fifteen pounds to make. Value added tax is then applied on top of the whole price including duty.
The practical effect is that on the cheapest bottle on the shelf, duty and tax account for the overwhelming majority of what you pay. There is very little room left for the gin itself.
This is why the quality difference between a five pound gin and a twenty pound gin is enormous, while the difference between a twenty five pound gin and a forty pound gin is much smaller. The extra money at the bottom of the range is almost all going into the liquid, because the tax component is already paid.
What does extra spending actually buy?
- Redistillation instead of compounding. The single biggest quality step. Distilled gin requires the botanicals to go through a still, which costs time, energy and yield.
- More and better botanicals. Real citrus peel, good juniper and quality roots cost considerably more than the minimum viable quantity of flavouring.
- One shot rather than concentrated production. Producing far fewer bottles from each distillation raises the cost per bottle substantially.
- Careful cuts and smaller batches. Discarding more of the run to keep only the best portion reduces yield and improves the result.
- Higher bottling strength. More alcohol per bottle means more duty, so a 47 per cent gin is inherently more expensive than the same recipe at 40.
What does it buy that is not in the liquid?
Packaging, principally. Heavy glass, ceramic bottles, embossing, cork stoppers, printed boxes and custom moulds are expensive, and a striking bottle is a marketing asset that shows up on the shelf and in photographs.
Small scale production is also inherently costly per bottle, which is a genuine cost rather than a margin, but it is a cost of the business model rather than a guarantee of a better drink. A small distillery can make mediocre gin and a large one can make excellent gin.
Where does the value peak?
For most drinkers, somewhere in the middle. Once you are into distilled gin from a producer using a proper botanical recipe at a decent strength, further spending buys refinement and novelty rather than a fundamentally better drink.
The exception is bottling strength, which does deliver a measurable benefit in cocktails and long drinks, and is worth paying for if you mix regularly.
How do you spot a bottle that is priced above its quality?
Check the category name and the strength first. A gin at exactly 37.5 per cent with an elaborate bottle and a premium price is charging you for glass. Check whether the producer names a distillery and describes the method, because those who use expensive processes almost always say so.
Be wary of very large botanical counts used as a headline, since the number is easy to inflate and hard to taste. Be similarly wary of the words small batch and craft, neither of which has any legal meaning in most markets.
Is expensive gin worth it?
For drinking neat or in a martini, where the gin is the drink, spending more usually shows. For a gin and tonic with a flavoured tonic and a heavy garnish, a good mid priced London dry does the job and the difference is largely lost.
The most efficient approach is to keep one reliable mid priced bottle for mixing and buy something more interesting occasionally for drinks where you will actually notice it.