Alcohol is not a neutral carrier. It contributes to how a drink tastes in several distinct ways, which is why removing it leaves such an obvious gap and why the same spirit at two strengths is a noticeably different experience.
It carries aroma
The largest effect.
A great many aromatic compounds are more soluble in alcohol than in water, so ethanol dissolves and holds flavours that water alone would not.
It also evaporates readily, carrying those compounds into the air above the drink where the nose can reach them.
Since most of what we experience as flavour arrives through the nose, that makes alcohol a significant part of the delivery system rather than merely a component.
It is why a non-alcoholic drink frequently smells of less than its ingredients suggest it should.
It contributes body
Ethanol is more viscous than water and produces a fuller, weightier sensation in the mouth.
That is why a spirit feels thicker than water and why a low-alcohol drink can taste watery even when the flavours are correct.
It is also the reason non-alcoholic products frequently add glycerine, gum arabic or other thickeners, which are attempting to replace a texture that has been removed.
It tastes sweet
Less obvious and genuinely true.
Ethanol has an intrinsic sweetness alongside a burn, which contributes to the perceived sweetness of a drink independently of any sugar.
Remove the alcohol and a recipe that was balanced becomes less sweet as well as thinner, which is part of why de-alcoholised wine frequently tastes sharp.
It numbs
At higher concentrations, ethanol has an anaesthetic effect on the nose and palate.
A cask strength spirit sniffed too closely can shut down the sense of smell temporarily, which is why the first approach to a strong spirit should be from a distance with the mouth slightly open.
Reducing the strength with a little water lessens the effect, which is a substantial part of why adding water opens a spirit up.
This is also why the second and third drinks of an evening taste of less than the first, which has nothing to do with the drinks.
The consequences for cocktails
A drink built on a spirit at forty five per cent will hold its ground where the same recipe with a spirit at forty vanishes behind the citrus and sugar.
That is worth knowing when a recipe seems to fail with your particular bottle: the ratio may be fine and the base too light.
Dilution is the counterweight. Too little and the alcohol dominates and numbs; too much and it stops carrying anything.
The correct dilution is the point where the aromatics are released and the burn has receded, which is what thirty seconds of stirring is aiming at.
The consequences for low-alcohol drinks
They have to work harder, and the good ones do it deliberately.
Acidity supplies the lift that alcohol would have provided.
Bitterness supplies the length and the adult character.
Tannin, from tea in particular, supplies the drying finish.
Salt amplifies everything else.
And texture has to be built in, whether through a syrup, a foam or an ingredient with body.
A well made low-alcohol drink is constructed around the absence rather than pretending it is not there, which is why the best ones do not attempt to imitate a specific cocktail.
Testing it
Take a cask strength spirit and taste it neat, then with a few drops of water, then with a little more.
The aroma changes noticeably at each stage, and the point at which it opens up is usually obvious.
It is the clearest demonstration available of what strength is actually doing, and it costs one measure.
Serving temperature interacts with it
Cold suppresses aroma and also suppresses the perception of alcohol, which is why a very cold strong drink tastes smoother than it is.
That is worth knowing, since it is part of why a well made cocktail conceals its strength so effectively.