Back to Technique

Which Cherries Should You Use?

Which Cherries Should You Use?
Simply Alcohol Team 11 April 2026

The cherry in a manhattan is the last thing you taste, which makes it a strange thing to economise on. The two products commonly sold under similar names are barely related.

The bright red kind

Made by bleaching cherries to remove their colour and flavour, then re-dyeing and sweetening them with syrup and flavouring.

The result is uniformly bright red, very sweet and slightly rubbery, with a synthetic almond-cherry flavour.

They are inexpensive, they keep indefinitely and they contribute a note that sits oddly against a well made drink.

The name maraschino is used for them, which causes confusion, since the original meaning is quite different.

Proper cocktail cherries

Whole cherries preserved in a syrup, frequently with maraschino liqueur, which is where the name originally came from.

They are dark, firm and genuinely good to eat, with a real cherry flavour and a bitter almond note from the stones.

They cost considerably more per jar and last a long time in the fridge, since a manhattan uses one.

Several producers make them, and the well known Italian version is the reference point, though good alternatives exist at lower prices.

Why it matters

Position, mostly.

The cherry sits at the bottom of the glass and is eaten at the end, so it is the final impression of the drink.

It also slowly contributes to the liquid as it sits, which means a heavily sweetened one adds sugar to a drink that was balanced without it.

For a manhattan or an old fashioned, which are drunk slowly, that is a real effect rather than a theoretical one.

Making your own

Straightforward and worth doing in season.

Take firm fresh cherries, stemmed and stoned or left whole depending on preference.

Make a syrup from equal weights of sugar and water with a strip of lemon peel and a cinnamon stick, warm it and take it off the heat.

Add the cherries and let them sit in the warm syrup for a few minutes to soften slightly.

Once cool, add a measure of brandy, bourbon or maraschino liqueur, around 100 millilitres per jar.

Refrigerate. They keep for several months thanks to the sugar and alcohol, and they improve for the first fortnight.

If you leave the stones in, the drink gains a faint almond note over time, which is traditional and a matter of preference.

Which drinks use them

The manhattan, where it is the standard garnish.

The old fashioned, though the modern preference is for an orange twist alone rather than muddled fruit.

The whiskey sour, alongside or instead of a lemon twist.

Tiki drinks, where a cherry alongside a pineapple wedge is conventional.

A cherry is also excellent simply eaten, and the syrup left in the jar is useful in drinks in its own right.

Storage

Refrigerate once opened, keep the cherries submerged in their syrup, and use a clean spoon or fork rather than fingers.

They keep for many months and the alcohol content in most versions preserves them well.

Do not throw away the syrup when the cherries run out, since it is a genuinely good ingredient in a whiskey drink.

Alcohol content

Worth mentioning, since a cherry is not an obvious source of it.

Many good cocktail cherries are preserved in a syrup containing liqueur or spirit, at a low but real level.

The quantity in a single cherry is negligible for most purposes, and anyone avoiding alcohol entirely should be told, since a garnish is easy to overlook when asking what is in a drink.

Alcohol-free versions exist and the label will say.

The name confusion

Worth clearing up, since it causes genuine difficulty when buying.

Maraschino is a clear cherry liqueur made from marasca cherries including the stones, used in the last word and the Hemingway daiquiri.

Maraschino cherry, in common usage, describes the bright red confectionery product, which contains no maraschino liqueur at all.

The two are unrelated despite the shared name, and a recipe calling for maraschino means the liqueur.