For the first fifteen years of the British craft beer movement, lager was largely absent from it. Small breweries made pale ales, IPAs, stouts and sours, and left lager to the multinationals. The reasons were practical rather than snobbish, and the recent arrival of craft lager on a serious scale is a genuine change.
Why small brewers avoided it
Lager occupies a tank for a long time. An ale can ferment and condition in a week or two; a properly lagered beer needs four to eight weeks or more at cold temperatures.
For a small brewery with a handful of tanks, that arithmetic is brutal. The same vessel could produce four batches of pale ale in the time it takes to make one batch of lager, and the lager will sell for a similar price. Cold conditioning also requires refrigeration capacity that a small operation may not have.
The second reason is technical. Lager exposes every flaw, since there is no ester character to mask a poor fermentation or an incomplete conditioning. A new brewery making a slightly imperfect IPA gets away with it; the same imperfection in a pilsner is immediately obvious.
Between the economics and the difficulty, lager was a poor bet for an emerging brewery, and the market was left to companies with the tanks and the expertise.
What changed
Several things. Breweries that survived the first wave grew large enough to afford dedicated tank space. Drinkers who had explored the outer reaches of hop-forward brewing began wanting something they could drink more than one of. And making lager well became a way for a brewery to demonstrate competence, which carries reputational value in a crowded market.
The result is a category that now covers everything from strict Czech and German interpretations to dry-hopped and unfiltered modern versions.
What the money buys
Three things, and they are real rather than notional.
All-malt brewing, with no rice or maize adjuncts, gives more body and a fuller bread and biscuit character. Longer conditioning produces a smoother, more integrated beer with the sulphur compounds properly resolved. And better hops, used in larger quantities, give aroma that mass market lager largely lacks.
Freshness is often the largest practical difference. A local lager reaching a shop within weeks of packaging tastes considerably more alive than one that has crossed a continent and sat in a warehouse.
Unfiltered versions retain yeast and protein that filtration would remove, giving a hazier appearance and a softer, fuller mouthfeel.
Whether it is worth it
For drinking attentively, yes, and the gap is wider than in some other styles. A good craft pilsner alongside a mass market lager is not a subtle comparison.
For drinking in quantity at a barbecue, the case is weaker, and there is no shame in buying inexpensive lager for a purpose it serves perfectly well.
The one thing worth watching is that craft lager is not automatically better. A rushed lager from a small brewery without the tank space to condition it properly can be worse than a competently made industrial one, and the style's unforgiving nature cuts both ways.
How to choose
Look for an indication of conditioning time or the words lagered, cold conditioned or a specific number of weeks, which brewers proud of the investment tend to mention.
Check the packaging date and buy the freshest available, since hop aroma fades fast in this style. Prefer cans, which protect against light entirely.
And decide which tradition you want. A brewery making a Czech-style pilsner with Saaz hops and decoction mashing is aiming at something quite different from one making a dry-hopped lager with New Zealand varieties, and both are legitimate. Trying one of each is the quickest way to establish which direction suits you.