Most beer declines slowly. Modern IPA declines fast, and the difference is not marginal. A hazy IPA at three months old is frequently a different beer from the one packaged, and not in a good direction.
Understanding why explains the emphasis brewers and specialist retailers place on dates, which can otherwise look like fussiness.
What is actually being lost
Hop aroma comes from volatile oils, and volatile means exactly what it sounds like. These compounds evaporate and, more importantly, oxidise readily, reacting with any oxygen present in the package.
The bright citrus and tropical fruit character degrades first, typically within weeks. What replaces it is a muted, vegetal quality, often described as oniony or garlicky, which is the most recognisable sign of a stale hoppy beer.
Malt oxidation follows, producing the classic stale flavours of wet cardboard, sherry and papery dryness.
Bitterness also softens over time, so an old IPA loses definition at both ends: less aroma at the front and less bite at the finish.
Why some styles fade faster
Hazy IPA is the most fragile beer in mainstream production. Its aroma depends entirely on dry hopping, its haze depends on protein and polyphenol structures that break down, and its low bitterness means there is little else to fall back on.
The realistic window is four to eight weeks from packaging, and beyond twelve weeks most examples are not worth buying.
West Coast IPA holds up somewhat better, since bitterness and a firmer malt structure survive longer than aroma does, and a three-month-old example is diminished rather than ruined.
Double IPA has more alcohol and malt to sustain it, though the hop character fades at the same rate.
The role of oxygen and packaging
Oxygen picked up during packaging is the main driver, and modern breweries go to considerable lengths to minimise it, purging cans with carbon dioxide and measuring dissolved oxygen in the finished product.
Cans are better than bottles for two reasons: they exclude light entirely, and the seal is more reliable than a crown cap over time.
Temperature matters enormously. Staling reactions roughly double in rate for every increase of several degrees, so a beer kept cold ages far more slowly than one in a warm room. Cold-chain distribution, where beer is refrigerated from brewery to shelf, exists specifically for this reason.
Reading dates properly
Two kinds of date appear on cans and they mean different things. A packaging or canning date tells you when the beer was filled, which is the figure you want. A best before date tells you when the brewery stops standing behind it, usually nine to twelve months later, which is far beyond the point at which a hoppy beer is at its best.
Breweries that print packaging dates are signalling confidence in their freshness, and it is a reasonable thing to favour when choosing between similar beers.
Where only a best before date appears, subtract the brewery's typical shelf life to estimate the fill date.
Practical rules
Buy hoppy beer from retailers with turnover and refrigerated stock. Check dates every time. Buy small quantities frequently rather than stockpiling, which is the opposite of the approach that works for wine.
Keep it in the fridge at home rather than in a cupboard, and drink it sooner than you think you need to.
And if an IPA tastes of onions, wet cardboard or nothing much, the beer is probably not to blame in the sense you might assume. It was likely very good two months ago.
What this means for buying habits
Hoppy beer is the one category where the wine approach to stocking up is actively wrong. A shelf of IPA bought on offer and worked through over six months will be disappointing for most of that period.
Buying four cans at a time from a shop with cold storage and turnover produces a better result than buying a case, even at a higher unit price. It is also worth noting that heavily discounted hoppy beer is frequently discounted because it is approaching the end of its useful life, which makes the saving less attractive than it appears.